These Thanksgiving sides haven’t changed in 50 years. And that’s a good thing!

Everyone talks about the turkey, but the Thanksgiving sides are what actually make this holiday shine. Most of the classics we still argue over came straight out of the 1950s, 60s, and 70s. They were simple then, and they’re simple now. No fancy culinary skills required… Just the same familiar comfort that made them stick around in the first place. Are you ready for the big day?

Green Bean Casserole

One of the easiest sides to make, this dish originated in 1955 by Dorcas Reilly in the Campbell’s test kitchen. It was when Campbell’s put this recipe directly on their cream of mushroom soup can that this became part of the holiday tradition in the 1960s.

A little bit of canned green beans, a generous pour of Campbell’s cream of mushroom soup, a sprinkle of French’s fried onions, and viola! Green bean casserole.

Want to make it? You can find the recipe for Campbell’s original green bean casserole here!

Jell-O Fruit Molds

The side dish that is loved or banned at the table. A Thanksgiving trend that took the family table by storm in the 1930s through the early 1960s. How wild is this recipe? Jell-O molded in a bunt cake pan (or similar), filled with canned fruit, Cool Whip, nuts, cottage cheese, and even vegetables?

I cannot stop laughing at this!

Personally, not appealing at all. I think I have PTSD from having to eat it at lunch… in preschool.

Want to make it? You can find an official Jell-O fruit mold recipe here!

Canned Cranberry Sauce

Cranberry sauce from a can is the absolute easiest side dish, as long as you have a can opener. Becoming mainstream in 1941, this concept actually came from a man by the name of Marcus Urann in 1912. Because of the short harvest season of cranberries, he wanted to come up with a way to sell them year round. And yes, he sold it under the Ocean Spray name. That’s him!

Need a slicing guide for the most even slices? Use the ridges left in this jellied cranberry log! This side dish adds some amazing flavor to the mashed potatoes and turkey. And even more amazing as a spread when making turkey sandwiches (or sliders) for the day 2 leftovers.

No recipe required. Just a trusty can opener! Canned cranberry is available at almost every grocery store.

Marshmallow Sweet Potatoes

This sweet and savory side dish began as more of a Northern tradition in 1917. Boston Cooking School Magazine founder Janet McKenzie Hill was hired by the Angelus Marshmallow Company to create recipes incorporating marshmallows as a main dish, versus simply a dessert. Her recipe book included this now popular dish, sweet upon sweet Thanksgiving goodness.

There are so many delicious ways to prepare a sweet potato casserole. This recipe here looks absolutely heavenly.

Boxed Stuffing

Now we’re talking about the ultimate Thanksgiving convenience food: Stove Top boxed stuffing. The original patent for “instant stuffing mix” was filed in 1971, hitting the store shelves a year or two later.

Prior to the invention of instant stuffing, you were required to prepare ingredients and cook the stuffing mix inside the bird. Which could pose a risk of salmonella not being properly cooked off as the stuffing takes longer to cook when inside the bird.

Instant stuffing eliminates this particular risk and Kraft (who now owns the brand) claims they still sell tens of millions of boxes of stuffing every year.

Stove Top boxed stuffing is available at almost every grocery store. Recipe on the box!

So, now that we’ve gone through the short history of some of the most popular, traditional Thanksgiving sides, are you ready for the big day? I hope you enjoy the holiday no matter what delicious (or not so delicious) foods are a part of your holiday tradition. 🧡

About the Author
80s baby. 90s kid. Nostalgia enthusiast! Former video game producer turned website consultant helping small businesses and brands create a successful online presence. Writing weekly throwbacks here at The Loftus Party.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *